These are the reasons people give for buying new, each compared with the data.
Excuse 1
"A used car is just someone else's problems."
Busted
New cars have problems too. J.D. Power's 2026 Initial Quality Study found 175 problems per 100 new vehicles in the first 90 days [6]. At three years old the figure is 204 per 100 [7]. That's only about 29 more problems per 100 cars after three years of driving.
Brand-new designs tend to be the least reliable. Consumer Reports has found that first- and second-year redesigns often drop in reliability, while models late in their run do best [8]. A used car has a track record you can check. A new one doesn't have one yet.
Do this: get a vehicle history report and pay an independent mechanic for a pre-purchase inspection. Look up the exact model year's reliability before you buy.
Excuse 2
"I want the warranty."
Busted
Certified pre-owned cars come with warranties too, and some last longer than the new-car coverage. Toyota's Gold certified program includes a 7-year / 100,000-mile powertrain warranty with a $0 deductible, after a 160-point inspection [9]. HondaTrue Certified also gives 7 years / 100,000 miles of powertrain coverage [10].
A 2–3 year old car is also often still inside its original factory coverage, and that transfers to the next owner.
Excuse 3
"New cars get cheap financing, used loans cost more."
Busted
The "cheap financing" is mostly an ad. Only 1.2% of new-car buyers who financed got a 0% deal [3]. Everyone else paid an average 7.0% APR [2].
A rate isn't a cost, dollars are. Used rates run higher (10.6% on average [2]), but they apply to a much smaller loan: $30,414 on average vs. $44,156 for new [3]. Over a ~70-month term that's roughly $9,800 vs $10,500 in interest, a wash. The used payment is still about $185 a month lower, and you skip the steepest years of depreciation, which dwarf any rate difference. Want no interest at all? Pay cash for a used car.
Excuse 4
"I can afford the monthly payment."
Busted
Buyers are keeping payments manageable by stretching loans longer. In Q2 2026, 36.5% of new-car loans ran 73+ months and 23.9% ran 84+ months, both records. One in five buyers took on a payment of $1,000 or more [3].
Long loans tend to leave you underwater. Nearly 30% of trade-ins toward new vehicles had negative equity, averaging $6,884. Those buyers rolled the debt into the next loan and averaged $944/month and $16,270 in interest [11].
Excuse 5
"A new car will make me happier."
Busted
University of Michigan psychologist Norbert Schwarz and Jing Xu found that people expected nicer cars to make them happier. But when drivers described their most recent drive, the car's value had no correlation at all with how they felt [12]. After the first few weeks, driving becomes routine and you stop noticing the car.
Regret is also common. In a LendingTree survey, nearly 40% of car buyers had regrets, and 10% said they'd bought a car they couldn't afford [13].
Excuse 6
"I need the latest safety tech."
Busted
Most of the major safety features are already on recent used cars. Twenty automakers pledged to make automatic emergency braking standard on at least 95% of their vehicles by September 2022, and ten of them hit that target by 2020 [14]. A 2021–2023 used car from a mainstream brand very likely has AEB.
Excuse 7
"I keep my cars forever, so depreciation doesn't matter."
Busted
Keeping a car a long time is an argument for buying used, not new. Keep it forever and you still pay for the first three years, the steepest part of the curve. On the average new car that's about $16,495 of value gone before a used buyer would even show up.
You don't need those years to get a long life out of a car. The average vehicle on U.S. roads is 12.8 years old [15], and a Toyota is 3.7 times as likely as the average car to reach 250,000 miles [21]. Buy at three years old, keep it just as long, and the first owner has paid for the most expensive part.
Excuse 8
"Used prices are so high, new is basically the same."
Busted
"Basically the same" is off by $22,850. The average used listing is $27,239 (Cox Automotive, August 2026) [16]. The average new car sells for $50,089 [1].
Used prices rising 7% in a year doesn't change that. New prices are high too, and a new car still takes its steepest drop the day you buy it. Invest that $22,850 at 25 and it's worth about $342,000 by 65 in today's dollars [19].
Excuse 9
"I'm paying cash, so I'm not wasting money."
Busted
Paying cash skips the interest, and that's all it skips. Interest is a separate problem from buying new, and it isn't the big one. At national averages, owning new instead of a 3-year-old version costs about $11,296 more over 5 years with no loan at all. That money goes to depreciation, the extra sales tax on the higher price, and upkeep. A check can't stop the car losing value.
You also don't buy just one car. Keep buying new instead of used, and that works out to about $188 a month. Invested from age 25 to 65 at a 7% return after inflation, it grows to about $465,000 in today's dollars [19].
Do this: pay cash for a 3–4 year old car and you avoid both costs. See what the money you keep grows to.
Excuse 10
"I'll just trade it in when I want something new."
Busted
Trading in early means you sell right after the steepest drop. Our model has an average new car losing about $13,574 of value in its first two years, and a trade-in locks that loss in.
If you still owe more than it's worth, the gap doesn't go away. It gets rolled into the next loan. Nearly 30% of trade-ins toward new vehicles carried negative equity, averaging $6,884 [11]. That's how people end up paying off two cars while driving one.
Excuse 11
"Older cars nickel-and-dime you with repairs."
Busted
Repairs do go up with age, but for a reliable brand they're small change next to depreciation. Consumer Reports owners spent about $5,950 on a Toyota over 10 years, and Buick owners about $4,100 in years 6–10, or roughly $820 a year [20]. A new car loses more than that in value in its first month or so.
Good cars also last. A Toyota has a 19.7% chance of reaching 250,000 miles, about 3.7 times the 5.4% average, and the Sequoia's chance is 42.3% [21]. The brand matters more than the age. Consumer Reports found Land Rover owners pay about four times what Buick and Lincoln owners do over 10 years [20].
Do this: buy a brand with a strong track record, get a pre-purchase inspection, and set aside about $100 a month for repairs. Compare the costs by age.
Excuse 12
"Four years old is as old as I'd go."
Busted
Stopping at four years leaves money on the table. In our model the same car at 8 years old costs about $6,979 less ($31,242 vs. $24,263). Once depreciation and a generous repair budget are both counted, it costs about the same or less per year to own.
That lower price is cash you keep. Invested at 25, the difference plus the sales tax you save could grow to about $112,000 by 65 in today's dollars [19]. At about 12,200 miles a year [18], an 8-year-old car has roughly 98,000 miles on it, which is middle age for a well-built car.